Back

Should AI have morals?

What happens when artificial intelligence starts flattering us instead of challenging us?

13 January 2026

Artificial intelligence is evolving fast — but as it gets friendlier, should we be worried it’s losing its grip on the truth?

We’re exploring a hot topic in both computer science and ethics: Should AI be built with morals, or is it enough for it to make you feel good? 

Spoiler alert — if your chatbot applauds your worst ideas, it might be time for a software update.

Let’s start with ChatGPT, specifically the GPT-4o update. This version of OpenAI’s popular AI assistant had one job: make users happy. It did this so well, it started agreeing with everything. People shared examples of it praising clearly harmful behaviour, reinforcing conspiracy theories, and even applauding dodgy life choices. Why? Because its success was measured on positive user feedback — essentially, how many people responded with smiley face emojis.

The result? A hype man in silicon form. Warm and fuzzy? Yes. Useful? Not so much. 

Eventually, OpenAI admitted it had gone too far and rolled back the overly agreeable behaviour. But the episode raised big questions about the purpose of AI. Should it be emotionally supportive at all costs, or should it sometimes challenge us?

Then there’s GrokElon Musk’s “anti-woke”, “truth-seeking” AI launched via X (formerly Twitter). Despite the branding, Grok began doing something unexpected: it corrected false claims, backed up scientific consensus, and even fact-checked Musk himself. It wasn’t trying to be political — just accurate. But that honesty proved controversial, especially for users who expected Grok to reinforce their existing views. Apparently, it’s all fun and games until the AI doesn’t flatter your worldview.

So, what do we actually want from AI? Is it more important that it makes us feel good — or helps us be better?

On one hand, supportive AIs can offer comfort and validation. But when they reinforce false beliefs or encourage risky decisions, the consequences can be serious. On the other hand, AIs that challenge misinformation and offer correction might feel uncomfortable in the moment — but they can help us grow. Just like that one teacher who was a little harsh with the red pen, but made you a stronger thinker.

This is about more than software — it’s about trust, responsibility, and the future of technology in society. Because if we build AI to agree with us no matter what, we’re not building intelligence. We’re building digital yes-men. And they might just smile and nod while we walk ourselves off a cliff.

So, where do you stand? 

Should AI be polite and supportive — or truthful, even if it stings?

Watch the full video here to explore the debate in full.

For more Lesson Hacker Videos, check out the Craig’n’Dave YouTube playlist HERE.

Be sure to visit our website for more insights into the world of technology and the best teaching resources for computer science and business studies.

Stay informed, stay curious!

Related posts

Four Revision Techniques That Actually Work

Stop wasting time on ineffective revision. Learn four proven techniques that improve recall, confidence and exam performance.

8 July 2026

KS3 logo

How can Craig’n’Dave say their new KS3 resources are “curriculum 2028 ready”?

It’s a fair question, so we’d like to explain exactly what we mean. First and foremost, we do not have […]

The Year 7 dip: why enthusiasm fades – and how to rebuild it

Why do so many pupils lose their enthusiasm after Year 7? Explore the research behind the motivation dip and practical ways teachers can reignite it.

7 July 2026

The social media debate: What it really means for schools

As social media regulation looms, what will it mean for schools? Explore the challenges, risks and opportunities for education.

20 June 2026

Teacher looking at a laptop computer.

June 2026 update

The June 2026 update to Smart Revise introduces a range of quality-of-life improvements requested by teachers and students. These updates […]

Coding in the age of AI: Why it still belongs in the classroom

As AI transforms the way we write software, should we stop teaching students to code? This blog explores why coding is about far more than programming – developing the critical thinking, problem-solving and digital literacy skills that will matter more than ever in an AI-driven world.

19 June 2026

Pearson – shaping the future of computing education

We caught up with Tim Brady, Subject Advisor for Computer Science and Digital at Pearson, to explore the future of computing education, evolving assessment, and why Pearson is proud to support this year’s Craig’n’Dave Festival of Computing.

18 June 2026

Why Do So Many Teachers Leave Teaching?

Craig and Dave share the story of why they eventually stepped away from full-time teaching after years in the profession.

17 June 2026

Social media app icons on a phone.

What the proposed UK social media changes mean for Craig’n’Dave teachers

You may have seen recent news coverage about the UK Government’s plans to introduce a ban on social media use […]